Hi Carl,
I just noticed by chance that when choosing the 1.90:1 Full Container, the ISDCF name gets _F-full-frame_ and not _C_ as it is recommended by the ISDCF (http://isdcf.com/dcnc/home/appendix-7-p ... ratio.html)
But I might be wrong.
I'm still (test) version 2.11.27.
Best wishes
Philipp
Aspect ratio on Full Container not labled as C
-
phili2p
- Posts: 41
- Joined: Sun Mar 08, 2015 10:38 am
-
Carsten
- Posts: 2804
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2014 9:11 pm
- Location: Germany
Re: Aspect ratio on Full Container not labled as C
This seems to be a leftover from http://dcpomatic.com/mantis/view.php?id=1118
The first, container designation is correct, depending on wether you choose Full, Flat or Scope - it is C, F, or S. The second, internal aspect ratio designator indeed goes wrong for an internal scaling to full container (1.90:1), but only for non-full container types:
Carl fixed something in recent versions, but it seems he missed this one.
Test_ADV-1_C-239_20_2K_20171115_IOP_OV
Test_ADV-1_S-full-frame_20_2K_20171115_IOP_OV
It seems there is an internal placeholder 'full-frame' for 1.90
Admittedly, it doesn't make much sense to put a full container aspect ratio into anything else than a full container (where DOM correctly creates
Test_ADV-1_C_20_2K_20171115_IOP_OV. But maybe not every 1.90 source is actually meant to be played in a full container.
I'll reopen that bug in Mantis.
- Carsten
The first, container designation is correct, depending on wether you choose Full, Flat or Scope - it is C, F, or S. The second, internal aspect ratio designator indeed goes wrong for an internal scaling to full container (1.90:1), but only for non-full container types:
Carl fixed something in recent versions, but it seems he missed this one.
Test_ADV-1_C-239_20_2K_20171115_IOP_OV
Test_ADV-1_S-full-frame_20_2K_20171115_IOP_OV
It seems there is an internal placeholder 'full-frame' for 1.90
Admittedly, it doesn't make much sense to put a full container aspect ratio into anything else than a full container (where DOM correctly creates
Test_ADV-1_C_20_2K_20171115_IOP_OV. But maybe not every 1.90 source is actually meant to be played in a full container.
I'll reopen that bug in Mantis.
- Carsten